A Comparison Between the Northern and Italian Renaissance

These two portraits are a good way of discussing some of the differences between the Northern Renaissance and the Italian Renaissance.

Northern Renaissance portrait: click here to read more about it.
Jean Hey or the Master of Moulins, Portrait of Margaret of Austria, oil on Panel, c. 1490 (Met)
Jean Hey? or the Master of Moulins, Portrait of
Margaret of Austria
, oil on panel, c. 1490 (Metropolitan Museum of Art)


Typical characteristics of the Northern Renaissance style

The artist has used the new medium of oil paint to depict the textures of objects. Notice the red velvet of the figure's dress, the shiny gold of her pendant, the pearlescent rosary beads held in her hands, and the lightly sparkling gold on the shawl over her head). Northern Renaissance artists were especially interested in depicting light on reflective surfaces. In this portrait, all the gold glistens and reflects the light—even the tiny row of beads that frame her face.

We also see that the artist seems to have painted her exactly the way she looks, with her lips pursed, and a small bump on the end of her nose. The artist did not idealize her features at all, which is another typical feature of Northern Renaissance art. Whereas the Italians had learned to idealize by studying the sculpture of classical antiquity, Northern Europeans were relatively less influenced by ancient Greek and Roman culture, in part because of their geographical distance.

Also typical for much of Northern Renaissance portraiture is the inclusion of a very elaborate landscape that seems to go on as far as the eye can see. These landscapes often contain numerous details, such as a castle, trees, a lake, hills, a town in the distance, light reflecting in the water—and the illusion of space created by atmospheric perspective. There are so many things to look at here, and the artist seems to be giving equal importance to all parts of the painting.

Also, this artist is using symbolism—something that is very typical of the Northern Renaissance. Click on the link above to find out what her pendant means!

 

Italian Renaissance portrait: click here to read more about it. Alesso Baldovinetti, Portrait of a Lady, tempera and oil on wood, c. 1465 (National Gallery, London)
Alesso Baldovinetti, Portrait of a Lady, tempera and oil on wood, c. 1465 (National Gallery, London)

Typical characteristics of the Italian Renaissance style
The artist does not focus so much on many small details. Instead, he generalizes in his depiction. The clothes, even the face, are not painted with as much attention to small details. The painting is not as clear and crisp as the Northern Renaissance portrait. Baldovinetti concentrates on depicting the sitter's face, which is shown in profile. Because he does not provide as much detail to other areas of the painting (to her clothes, the background, etc.), they don't seem as important, and as a result, we refocus our attention on the particular individual portrayed.

A word about portraits in general: only people who were very rich could afford to have their portrait painted, and it was something that you did only once in your life. The portrait had to be formal, and it was very much about your social status. For this reason, you did not show yourself in your pajamas in the morning!

The portrait above was typical for the Early Italian Renaissance, in that it cuts off at the bust and does not include the hands. In the High Renaissance (as we will see with the Mona Lisa), Leonardo begins a new formula for portraiture, which includes a frontal face, 3/4 shoulders, and the sitter's hands.

Your Comments (0)

Add Comments

We think Smarthistory works best when it prompts discussion. Please post (on-topic) comments, (constructive) criticism, and praise (we love praise).*

Maybe you only have hazy memories of a dark auditorium, a soporific voice, and hundreds of slides of Mary and baby Jesus; perhaps you have a love of museums, but have no experience with art history.

Or, maybe you're a designer, an illustrator, a museum educator, a conservator or curator, or even (gasp!) an art historian. Whatever your background, we welcome your thoughts and ideas.

*All comments are moderated

To post a comment, you need the Adobe Flash Plugin. Download it from here.

Where and When

1400-1500 Renaissance in Italy and the North
Italy and the North
1400-1500
This work is an open educational resource and This work is licensed under a Creative Common Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 license.